Published opinion
What did the court decide in United States v. Restitullo?
Disposition: the motion to suppress was granted as to the client's statements. The client had been read his Miranda rights and asked for a lawyer. Minutes later, after an unrecorded exchange with officers in a hallway, he agreed to talk and gave a statement that lasted about three hours. Under Edwards v. Arizona, 451 U.S. 477 (1981), the Government had to prove that the client, not the police, re-started the conversation. The court found the Government failed to prove it and held that officers violated the client's Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. The opinion is published at 215 F. Supp. 3d 343.
| Citation | United States v. Restitullo, 215 F. Supp. 3d 343 (D.N.J. 2016) |
|---|---|
| Court | United States District Court for the District of New Jersey (Newark) |
| Judge | Senior U.S. District Judge William H. Walls |
| Docket | No. 15-cr-00394 (WHW) |
| Hearing / decided | August 23, 2016 / October 18, 2016 |
| Counsel for defendant | Mario M. Blanch, Esq. |
| Counsel for the Government | U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of New Jersey |
| Ruling | Motion to suppress granted as to the client's statements (denied as to items seized from the home) |
| Published? | Yes — Federal Supplement, Third Series, volume 215, page 343 |
| Read the opinion | CourtListener · Google Scholar |
Why a published opinion matters
Most trial-court rulings on suppression motions are never published. A published opinion is printed in the official reporter — here, the Federal Supplement, Third Series — so judges, prosecutors and defense lawyers can find it and cite it in later cases. A federal district court decision is persuasive rather than binding on other courts, but Restitullo is now part of the body of law on what happens when police keep pressing a suspect who has asked for a lawyer, and on how the inevitable discovery doctrine applies when officers have started, but not finished, a search warrant.
What happened
The client was arrested by the Hudson County Prosecutor's Office and taken to the Special Victims Unit in Jersey City. A detective read him his Miranda rights. He signed a waiver form, but when the detective began preparing a consent-to-search form, he said he did not want to talk or sign anything and asked for a lawyer. The detective stopped the interview and walked him out toward a holding cell.
What happened in the hallway over the next three minutes was not recorded. The client said that a sergeant got in his face and pressed him to go back in and give a statement. The Government said the client started the conversation by asking about a family member, and the sergeant simply told him to be honest. Either way, the client went back into the interview room, waived his rights, signed a consent to search his home and gave a statement that lasted about three hours. The case was later charged in federal court.
How Mario got the statement suppressed
1. He framed the motion around the Edwards bright-line rule. Once a suspect in custody asks for a lawyer, police may not question him again until a lawyer is present — unless the suspect himself starts a new conversation about the investigation (Edwards v. Arizona; Maryland v. Shatzer, 559 U.S. 98 (2010)). The Third Circuit applies the two-step test from Oregon v. Bradshaw, 462 U.S. 1039 (1983): first, did the suspect initiate the conversation; second, was the waiver knowing, intelligent and voluntary (United States v. Velasquez, 885 F.2d 1076 (3d Cir. 1989)).
2. He put the burden where it belongs. The Government, not the defendant, had to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the client re-started the conversation after asking for counsel (Colorado v. Connelly, 479 U.S. 157 (1986)). Because the hallway exchange was not recorded, the case turned on the officers' testimony.
3. He tested that testimony on cross-examination. At the August 2016 hearing, the detective testified that she did not remember the hallway conversation — who spoke first, what was said, or how she learned the client had changed his mind. The sergeant testified that the client started it and that he only told him to be honest.
4. He used the Government's own video against its witness. In the recorded second interview, the detective had asked the client why he changed his mind. He answered that it was because of the one statement the sergeant made — that if he really cared about his family member, he would talk. The court relied on that contemporaneous answer, found that it contradicted the sergeant's account, and found that the sergeant had tried to play down what he said.
5. The court ruled for the defense at step one. The court held that the Government had not shown the client initiated the conversation, so it did not need to reach step two. It found that officers violated the client's Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination by pressing him to give a statement immediately after he asked for counsel, and it suppressed the entire second interview.
What the court did not suppress
The defense also moved to suppress the items seized from the home. The court denied that part of the motion under the inevitable discovery doctrine of Nix v. Williams, 467 U.S. 431 (1984). It reasoned that, before the consent was signed, a detective had already drafted a search-warrant affidavit based on independent witness interviews, probable cause was strong, and officers had secured the home, so the items would inevitably have been found under a warrant. The court noted that it is generally reluctant to apply that exception when police never obtain a warrant, and it explained why other federal circuits have refused to apply it when officers simply skip the warrant process.
Why it matters if you are being questioned
- Ask for a lawyer clearly, then stop talking. Once you ask, the police must stop questioning you. If they keep pressing, any statement that follows can be challenged.
- Unrecorded moments matter. Hallway talk, "off the record" comments and pressure about family members are exactly what a suppression hearing tests.
- Cross-examination wins suppression motions. The judge decides who is credible. Prior reports, video and the officers' own words are the tools.
- New Jersey law can protect you even more. New Jersey courts apply their own state-law privilege against self-incrimination and require the State to prove a valid waiver beyond a reasonable doubt in state prosecutions. See motions to suppress evidence in New Jersey.
Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
The law: key statutes, court rules and cases
| Authority | What it means |
|---|---|
| United States v. Restitullo, 215 F. Supp. 3d 343 (D.N.J. 2016) | Published opinion: statements suppressed under Edwards because the Government failed to prove the defendant re-initiated conversation after asking for counsel; home evidence admitted under inevitable discovery. |
| Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966) | Police must warn a person in custody of the right to remain silent and the right to a lawyer before interrogation. |
| Edwards v. Arizona, 451 U.S. 477 (1981) | After a suspect asks for a lawyer, police-initiated questioning must stop until counsel is present, unless the suspect re-initiates. |
| Oregon v. Bradshaw, 462 U.S. 1039 (1983) | Two-step test: did the suspect initiate further conversation, and was the later waiver knowing, intelligent and voluntary. |
| United States v. Velasquez, 885 F.2d 1076 (3d Cir. 1989) | Third Circuit adopts the Bradshaw test. |
| Maryland v. Shatzer, 559 U.S. 98 (2010) | Explains the Edwards rule and why repeated attempts at interrogation carry a greater risk of coercion. |
| Colorado v. Connelly, 479 U.S. 157 (1986) | In federal court, the prosecution must prove a Miranda waiver by a preponderance of the evidence. |
| Nix v. Williams, 467 U.S. 431 (1984) | Inevitable discovery: evidence is admitted if the prosecution proves it would have been found by lawful means. |
Every authority links to its source: statutes to Justia, opinions to CourtListener, Justia or the New Jersey Courts, court rules to the New Jersey Courts. Summaries are general information, not legal advice.
Read the opinion
Frequently asked questions
What does it mean that United States v. Restitullo is a published opinion?
It means the decision is printed in the official reporter, the Federal Supplement, Third Series, at volume 215, page 343. Published opinions can be found and cited by judges and lawyers in later cases. A federal district court opinion is persuasive authority: other courts may follow its reasoning, but it is not binding precedent on them.
Can the police keep questioning me after I ask for a lawyer?
No. Under Edwards v. Arizona, 451 U.S. 477 (1981), once a person in custody asks for a lawyer, police must stop the interrogation until a lawyer is present, unless the person starts the conversation again. If the police re-start it, a later waiver is not valid and the statement can be suppressed. That is what happened in United States v. Restitullo.
Who has to prove that I re-started the conversation with the police?
The prosecution. In Restitullo, the court required the Government to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant initiated further conversation after asking for counsel. Because the officers could not credibly show that, the statement was suppressed.
If my statement is suppressed, is the whole case dismissed?
Not necessarily. Suppression keeps the statement out of the prosecution's case, which can change the strength of the case and the options for resolving it. Other evidence may still be admitted. In Restitullo, the court suppressed the statement but allowed items seized from the home under the inevitable discovery doctrine of Nix v. Williams, 467 U.S. 431 (1984).