ATTORNEY ADVERTISING Se habla español 24/7 access to an attorney
1-833-NY-NJ-LAW Emergency Text Client Portal
BLANCH LEGAL FIRMATTORNEYS AT LAW

Landmark New Jersey Supreme Court decision

State v. Saavedra: Mario M. Blanch, Esq. Made New Jersey Law

Mario M. Blanch, Esq. argued State v. Saavedra, 222 N.J. 39 (2015), before the New Jersey Supreme Court. The Court affirmed the denial of the motion to dismiss the indictment and remanded the case for trial. It held that the employee could argue at trial that her intent to use the documents in her discrimination case supported a claim-of-right or other justification defense, if the trial evidence supported it. After the remand, the prosecutor dismissed the case.

Call 1-833-NY-NJ-LAW Free consultation

★★★★★ 5.0-star Google ratingLicensed in New Jersey & New YorkPracticing since 2004Hablamos español

Mario made law

What did State v. Saavedra establish?

Disposition: the Supreme Court affirmed the denial of the motion to dismiss the indictment and remanded the case for trial. It held that the State had made a prima facie showing to the grand jury, that the State did not withhold exculpatory evidence or a required defense charge, and that Quinlan v. Curtiss-Wright Corp., 204 N.J. 239 (2010), a civil decision, does not govern the criminal laws at issue. At the same time, the Court held that the employee could assert at trial that her intent to use the documents in her discrimination case gave rise to a claim-of-right or other justification defense, if the trial evidence supported it — to be evaluated on a full record of her conduct, the content of the documents, the employer's policies and the privacy laws involved. Mario M. Blanch, Esq. argued the case for the employee. After remand, the prosecutor dismissed the case.

CitationState v. Saavedra, 222 N.J. 39 (2015)
CourtSupreme Court of New Jersey
DocketA-68-13 (073793)
Argued / decidedNovember 10, 2014 / June 23, 2015
Counsel for appellantMario M. Blanch, Esq. (argued)
Counsel for respondentHudson County Prosecutor's Office
DecisionAffirmed and remanded, 6–1 (opinion by Justice Patterson; Justice Albin dissented)
Final outcomeAfter remand, the prosecutor dismissed the case.
Official opinionRead the opinion on njcourts.gov (PDF)

Background

The defendant, a clerk employed by the North Bergen Board of Education, had sued the Board under the Law Against Discrimination and the Conscientious Employee Protection Act. Without permission, she removed confidential records that she took for use in her lawsuit. After the records surfaced in discovery, she was indicted for second-degree official misconduct and third-degree theft of public documents.

The legal question

The trial court denied her motion to dismiss the indictment, and the Appellate Division affirmed over a dissent. On appeal, Mario argued that the indictment should be dismissed and that it conflicted with the Court's civil decision in Quinlan v. Curtiss-Wright Corp., which protects some employees who use employer documents in discrimination cases.

The decision

The Court affirmed the denial of the motion to dismiss, 6–1. It held that the State presented a prima facie case to the grand jury, did not withhold exculpatory information or a charge on a defense it was required to give, and that Quinlan, a civil decision, does not govern the criminal statutes at issue. But the Court left the door open at trial: the employee could argue that her intent to use the documents in her discrimination case gave rise to a claim-of-right defense under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-2(c) or another justification, if the trial evidence supported it, and the trial court would evaluate that on a full record. Justice Albin dissented and would have dismissed the indictment.

The opinion is a published, precedential decision that defense lawyers and employment lawyers still cite on two points: what a prosecutor must present to a grand jury, and how an employee who gathers documents to prove discrimination can defend a criminal charge.

The outcome for the client

The case was remanded to the trial court. After the remand, the prosecutor dismissed the case.

Why it matters

  • For employees and whistleblowers: it defines when gathering evidence of discrimination can be defended in a criminal case, and what a jury will weigh.
  • For criminal defense: it confirms that a claim-of-right or justification defense can be raised at trial even when the indictment stands.
  • For grand jury practice: it addresses what a prosecutor must present to a grand jury — see grand jury and indictments and how to dismiss an indictment in New Jersey.

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

The law: key statutes, court rules and cases

AuthorityWhat it means
State v. Saavedra, 222 N.J. 39 (2015)Affirmed denial of a motion to dismiss the indictment; held the employee could assert a claim-of-right or justification defense at trial if the evidence supported it; Quinlan does not govern the criminal laws at issue.
Quinlan v. Curtiss-Wright Corp., 204 N.J. 239 (2010)Civil totality-of-the-circumstances test for when an employee's taking or use of employer documents is protected under the LAD.
N.J.S.A. 2C:20-2(c)Claim-of-right defense to theft.
N.J.S.A. 2C:30-2Official misconduct.

Every authority links to its source: statutes to Justia, New Jersey opinions to CourtListener, U.S. Supreme Court opinions to Justia, court rules to the New Jersey Courts. Summaries are general information, not legal advice.

Official court resources and forms

The courts publish their own explanations and forms. They are useful background, and a lawyer can tell you which ones apply to your case.

Related pages

Call now Free consultation
REAL EMERGENCIES ONLY

Please use your mobile phone

This computer doesn’t have a texting app. Open this page on your phone and tap Emergency Text — it texts Mario directly. Or call the office right now.

Call 1-833-NY-NJ-LAW