Quick answer
Does the prosecutor have to give me all the evidence in New Jersey?
Yes, once you are indicted. Post-indictment discovery under Court Rule 3:13-3(b) is automatic and broad: the State must make its file available — police reports, statements, recordings, lab and expert reports, and the grand jury transcript — and the rule says discovery “shall include exculpatory information or material.” Before indictment, the State must give full discovery when it makes a pre-indictment plea offer, and it must always disclose exculpatory information. The duty continues through trial.
How we get the evidence, step by step
- At the detention hearing. If the prosecutor asks the court to hold you in jail before trial, R. 3:4-2(c)(1)(B) requires the State to provide the statements and reports relating to its detention application and to disclose all exculpatory evidence. In State v. Robinson, 229 N.J. 44 (2017), the New Jersey Supreme Court spelled out what that means: the complaint, the Public Safety Assessment, the affidavit of probable cause, any preliminary law enforcement incident report (PLEIR), and the statements and reports behind the facts the State relies on. In cases where the State does not seek detention, it must provide the PLEIR and the material used to establish probable cause (R. 3:4-2(c)(1)(A)).
- If there is a pre-indictment plea offer. Under R. 3:13-3(a), when the prosecutor makes a plea offer before indictment, it must give defense counsel the available discovery at the time of the offer, subject to limited exceptions — and, regardless of those exceptions, “any exculpatory information or material.” You should never have to accept or reject a plea without seeing the evidence.
- After indictment — automatic discovery. When an indictment is returned or unsealed, the prosecutor must provide the discovery package with the indictment (R. 3:9-1(a)). The Supreme Court described this in State v. Scoles, 214 N.J. 236 (2013): the defendant’s “post-indictment right to discovery is automatic,” and “the onus is on the State to make the full file available.” This is when we receive the grand jury transcript, which we read line by line against the police reports and video.
- Targeted requests and motions to compel. Discovery packages are often incomplete. We send specific written requests — 911 calls and CAD logs, body-worn and dash camera video, surveillance footage, lab bench notes, Alcotest data and calibration records, phone extractions, and cooperation or plea agreements with witnesses — and we move to compel when the State does not produce them.
- A continuing duty. The State’s obligation does not end when it hands over the first box of discovery. If it later obtains more discoverable material, it must promptly disclose it (R. 3:13-3(f)).
In municipal court (DWI, traffic and disorderly persons cases), discovery is not automatic: the defense makes a written request under R. 7:7-7, and the prosecutor must respond. We send that request with our letter of representation.
What the prosecution has to turn over
After indictment, R. 3:13-3(b)(1) requires discovery of the relevant material in the State’s file, including:
- Exculpatory information or material — anything that tends to show you are not guilty, or less guilty, or that undercuts the State’s witnesses.
- Your own statements and those of co-defendants, whether written, recorded or summarized in a report.
- Police reports, photographs, video and audio recordings, including body-worn camera footage.
- The names and addresses of people with relevant knowledge, and their statements.
- Results and reports of scientific tests, experiments and examinations, and the names and reports of the State’s experts.
- Records of grand jury testimony, warrants and the materials behind them, and the criminal records of State witnesses.
The rule is a floor, not a ceiling. As State v. Scoles, 214 N.J. 236 (2013) explains, a criminal defendant “is entitled to broad discovery,” and courts may order more than the rule requires when justice demands it.
Exculpatory evidence: Brady, Giglio and New Jersey law
The prosecution’s duty to disclose favorable evidence is constitutional, not just a court rule. In Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963), the U.S. Supreme Court held that “suppression by the prosecution of evidence favorable to an accused upon request violates due process where the evidence is material either to guilt or to punishment, irrespective of the good faith or bad faith of the prosecution.” In Giglio v. United States, 405 U.S. 150 (1972), the Court extended that rule to evidence that undercuts a witness: “When the reliability of a given witness may well be determinative of guilt or innocence, nondisclosure of evidence affecting credibility falls within this general rule.” That covers promises, plea deals, immunity and payments to cooperating witnesses.
The duty reaches beyond the prosecutor’s own desk. Under Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419 (1995), “the individual prosecutor has a duty to learn of any favorable evidence known to the others acting on the government’s behalf in the case, including the police.”
New Jersey courts apply a three-part test, restated in State v. Brown, 236 N.J. 497 (2019): the evidence must be (1) favorable to the defense, because it is exculpatory or impeaching; (2) suppressed by the prosecution, whether purposely or inadvertently; and (3) material, meaning there is a reasonable probability that disclosure would have changed the result. In Brown, the Court found a Brady violation and ordered a new trial.
Common examples of exculpatory and impeachment evidence include:
- A witness who identified someone else, or could not identify you.
- Prior inconsistent statements of the complaining witness or an officer.
- Lab results that exclude you, or that were never run after being requested.
- Video that contradicts the police report.
- Deals, benefits or pending charges of a cooperating witness.
- Information bearing on an officer’s credibility.
When the State does not turn it over
If the prosecution fails to provide discovery, the court can order it produced, grant a continuance, bar the State from using the undisclosed evidence, or enter another appropriate order (R. 3:13-3). A Brady violation discovered after trial can require a new trial, as in Brown. And if exculpatory evidence was kept from the grand jury, the indictment itself may be challenged — see how to dismiss an indictment in New Jersey.
Do I have to give the prosecutor anything?
Some. Once the State provides discovery, the defense has reciprocal obligations under R. 3:13-3(b)(2) — for example, reports of experts the defense intends to call and the names of defense witnesses. Your own statements to your lawyer remain privileged. We manage reciprocal discovery so it does not hand the State a roadmap.
New York works differently. For the New York rules, see New York discovery under CPL Article 245.
The law: key statutes, court rules and cases
| Authority | What it means |
|---|---|
| R. 3:13-3 | Pre-indictment discovery with a plea offer, automatic post-indictment discovery including exculpatory material, reciprocal discovery, and the continuing duty to disclose. |
| R. 3:9-1(a) | The discovery package must be provided with the indictment. |
| R. 3:4-2(c)(1) | Discovery at the first appearance and at pretrial detention hearings; all exculpatory evidence must be disclosed. |
| R. 7:7-7 | Discovery in municipal court, on written request. |
| Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963) | Suppressing favorable, material evidence violates due process regardless of the prosecutor’s good or bad faith. |
| Giglio v. United States, 405 U.S. 150 (1972) | Evidence affecting a key witness’s credibility, including promises and deals, must be disclosed. |
| Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419 (1995) | The prosecutor must learn of favorable evidence known to the police and others acting for the government. |
| State v. Brown, 236 N.J. 497 (2019) | New Jersey’s three-part Brady test; a Brady violation required a new trial. |
| State v. Scoles, 214 N.J. 236 (2013) | Post-indictment discovery is automatic and broad; the State must make its full file available. |
| State v. Robinson, 229 N.J. 44 (2017) | What the State must disclose at a pretrial detention hearing. |
Every authority links to its source: statutes to Justia, New Jersey opinions to CourtListener, U.S. Supreme Court opinions to Justia, court rules to the New Jersey Courts. Summaries are general information, not legal advice.
Official court resources and forms
The courts publish their own explanations and forms. They are useful background, and a lawyer can tell you which ones apply to your case.
Frequently asked questions
When do I get discovery in a New Jersey criminal case?
In indictable cases, the full discovery package comes with the indictment (R. 3:9-1(a)). Earlier, the State must provide limited discovery for a detention hearing, and full discovery if it makes a pre-indictment plea offer. In municipal court, discovery is provided on written request.
Does the prosecutor have to turn over evidence that helps me?
Yes. Exculpatory evidence must be disclosed at every stage — at detention hearings, with pre-indictment plea offers, and after indictment — under R. 3:13-3 and the due process rule of Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963).
What is Brady material?
Evidence favorable to the accused that is material to guilt or punishment, including evidence that impeaches a prosecution witness (Giglio v. United States, 405 U.S. 150 (1972)). In New Jersey, a violation requires favorable evidence, suppressed by the State, that is material (State v. Brown, 236 N.J. 497 (2019)).
Can I get the grand jury transcript?
Yes. After indictment, the record of the grand jury testimony is part of discovery. It is the starting point for any motion to dismiss the indictment.
What happens if the prosecutor hides evidence?
The court can order disclosure, delay the trial, bar the State from using the evidence, or enter another remedy. If the hidden evidence was material, a conviction can be reversed and a new trial ordered.
Do I have to give the prosecutor my evidence?
Only limited reciprocal discovery under R. 3:13-3(b)(2), such as expert reports and the names of witnesses the defense intends to call. Your communications with your lawyer are privileged.
General information only, not legal advice. Laws change; figures reflect statutes as of November 2026.