Quick answer
When is criminal mischief a felony in New York?
When the damage exceeds $250 (class E), $1,500 (class D), or involves an explosive (class B).
Criminal mischief
| Charge | Conduct | Class and range |
|---|---|---|
| Criminal mischief 4th — Penal Law § 145.00 | Intentionally or recklessly damaging another's property, among other conduct | Class A misdemeanor |
| Criminal mischief 3rd — Penal Law § 145.05 | Damage over $250, or breaking into vehicles with prior convictions | Class E felony |
| Criminal mischief 2nd — Penal Law § 145.10 | Damage over $1,500 | Class D felony |
| Criminal mischief 1st — Penal Law § 145.12 | Damage by means of an explosive | Class B felony |
Arson
| Charge | Conduct | Class and range |
|---|---|---|
| Arson 4th — Penal Law § 150.05 | Recklessly damaging a building or vehicle by intentionally starting a fire | Class E felony |
| Arson 3rd — Penal Law § 150.10 | Intentionally damaging a building or vehicle by fire or explosion | Class C felony |
| Arson 2nd — Penal Law § 150.15 | Intentional fire with another person present | Class B violent felony; 5 to 25 years |
| Arson 1st — Penal Law § 150.20 | Explosive or incendiary device with a person present, or causing serious injury, among other factors | Class A-I felony |
How are these charges defended?
- Value of damage: repair estimates are often inflated, and value decides the degree.
- Ownership: damaging property you own or have a right to is not criminal mischief.
- Cause of the fire: arson cases often turn on fire-origin experts, which can be challenged.
- Recklessness versus intent, which separates arson 4th from arson 3rd.
The law: key statutes, court rules and cases
| Authority | What it means |
|---|---|
| Penal Law § 145.00 | Criminal mischief in the fourth degree. |
| Penal Law § 145.05 | Criminal mischief in the third degree. |
| Penal Law § 145.10 | Criminal mischief in the second degree. |
| Penal Law § 150.05 | Arson in the fourth degree. |
| Penal Law § 150.10 | Arson in the third degree. |
| Penal Law § 150.15 | Arson in the second degree. |
| Penal Law § 150.20 | Arson in the first degree. |
Every authority links to its source: statutes to Justia, New Jersey opinions to CourtListener, U.S. Supreme Court opinions to Justia, court rules to the New Jersey Courts. Summaries are general information, not legal advice.
Official court resources and forms
The courts publish their own explanations and forms. They are useful background, and a lawyer can tell you which ones apply to your case.
Frequently asked questions
When is criminal mischief a felony in New York?
When the damage exceeds $250 (class E), $1,500 (class D), or involves an explosive (class B).
Is arson always a felony?
Arson in the fifth degree is a misdemeanor; arson in the fourth through first degree are felonies.
Can a fire case be defended with expert testimony?
Yes. Many arson cases depend on the origin-and-cause analysis, which a defense expert can review and challenge.
General information only, not legal advice. Laws change; figures reflect statutes as of November 2026.