By Mario M. Blanch, Esq. · Published
The result
From a 20-year prison offer to a non-criminal violation
Two brothers were arrested in Rockland County, New York, on charges that included kidnapping in the second degree, robbery in the second degree and burglary in the second degree — violent felonies carrying mandatory state prison. Both were remanded to the Rockland County Jail, and the prosecutor's first offer was 20 years in state prison. The case was downgraded to harassment in the second degree, a non-criminal violation, with a one-year conditional discharge. No jail, no probation and no criminal record.
| Where | Rockland County, New York (arrest by the Spring Valley Police Department; arraignment in Spring Valley Justice Court) |
|---|---|
| Charges at arrest | Kidnapping in the second degree (Penal Law § 135.20); robbery in the second degree (Penal Law § 160.10); burglary in the second degree (Penal Law § 140.25); grand larceny in the fourth degree (Penal Law § 155.30); assault in the third degree (Penal Law § 120.00); harassment in the second degree (Penal Law § 240.26) |
| Status after arraignment | Remanded to the Rockland County Jail |
| Prosecutor's first offer | 20 years in state prison |
| Resolution | Harassment in the second degree (Penal Law § 240.26) — a violation, not a crime |
| Sentence | One-year conditional discharge |
| Defense counsel | Mario M. Blanch, Esq. |
What the brothers were facing
Each top charge is a "violent felony offense" under Penal Law § 70.02, which means a determinate state prison sentence on conviction:
- Kidnapping in the second degree (Penal Law § 135.20) is a class B violent felony carrying 5 to 25 years.
- Robbery in the second degree (Penal Law § 160.10) is a class C violent felony carrying 3½ to 15 years.
- Burglary in the second degree (Penal Law § 140.25) is a class C violent felony carrying 3½ to 15 years.
Sentences on multiple counts can run consecutively, and a violent felony conviction would also have meant years of post-release supervision. That is why the prosecutor's opening offer was 20 years.
Where the case ended: a violation, not a crime
Harassment in the second degree under Penal Law § 240.26 is a violation. Under New York law a violation is not a crime (Penal Law § 10.00), and the official records of a case that ends in a violation conviction are generally sealed (CPL 160.55). The one-year conditional discharge means no jail and no probation officer — only the condition that the brothers stay out of trouble for a year (Penal Law § 65.05). Going from a 20-year offer to a non-criminal violation is about as large a swing as a criminal case can take.
How cases like this are defended
The details of this case remain confidential. In general, serious charges like these are defended by:
- Separating the charges from the evidence. Arrest charges are an accusation. Discovery under CPL 245.20 — video, phone records, medical records, statements — often tells a different story than the complaint.
- Testing the kidnapping count. Kidnapping requires an "abduction" (Penal Law § 135.00), and a restraint that is merely incidental to another crime generally cannot support a separate kidnapping conviction (People v. Levy, 15 N.Y.2d 159 (1965)).
- Testing force and injury. Robbery requires forcible stealing, and assault and robbery in the second degree often turn on whether a "physical injury" is actually proved.
- Challenging the complainant's account with timelines, messages and the relationship between the people involved.
- Preparing for trial from day one, which is what moves a prosecutor off an opening offer.
Facing charges in Rockland County or anywhere in New York?
Read more about kidnapping, robbery, burglary and New York criminal defense, or see our Rockland County page. If you or a family member has been arrested, call 1-833-NY-NJ-LAW for a free, confidential consultation.
Client names and confidential details are withheld. A first offer is the prosecutor's opening position, not a sentence. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Talk to a lawyer about your case
If you are facing a charge or a family court matter in New Jersey or New York, request a free consultation or call 1-833-NY-NJ-LAW. See also: New Jersey criminal defense, New York criminal defense, Appeals.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The law may have changed since it was written. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.