By Mario M. Blanch, Esq. · Published
"I am the LORD, and there is no other, besides me there is no God; I equip you, though you do not know me." Isaiah 45:5
The problem with calibration certificates issued after the calibration of an Alcotest is that they are only as good as the data and procedures used to calibrate the underlying solutions and equipment. When a blanket calibration certificate becomes the standard, there is no way to challenge the calibration of the Alcotest because judges, prosecutors and defense attorneys become complacent and fail to scrutinize the production of the calibration certificates.
In essence, the calibration certificate becomes the only source of reliability. If the calibration certificate becomes the only source of reliability, then the certificate becomes infallible and challenging an Alcotest reading by a defense attorney becomes nothing more than an exercise to see if the calibration certificates have been provided as part of the discovery. Our jobs as defense attorneys should be more than just "rubber stamping" the documentation given to us by the prosecution.
Part of the "standard" discovery provided by the prosecutor in every Driving Under the Influence ("DUI") case is the calibration certificates supposedly proving that the Alcotest was properly calibrated and is accurate.
In New Jersey it is the burden of the State to show that the Alcotest is operating appropriately by "clear and convincing evidence." State v. Cassidy, 235 N.J. 482 (2018).
The problem with these calibration certificates is that they cannot be verified. There is no underlying data or documentation to show that the calibration was done correctly. In fact, the only document Draeger provides is a Certificate of Accuracy for the Alcotest and the Breath Simulator. The solutions utilized to calibrate the Alcotest are calibrated by Guth, and no certificates as to their testing is provided by Guth or Draeger.
Dr. Scott D. Hahn, PhD, in his article Ensuring Reproducible Data in the Laboratory (2020), stated, "Generating reproducible results is the key to good science. These reproducible results verify new discoveries, demonstrate competence in measurements, and enable clear communication of technical outcomes to other scientists."
The calibration and accuracy certificates provided by Draeger and the State of New Jersey provide no data, and are not provided with an accreditation seal.
It is time for the defense bar to insist on the data and procedures utilized to generate these Certificates of Accuracy and the Calibration Certificates.
Absent the ability of the defense bar to provide these documents to an expert or to replicate the process, there is no way of verifying the data or the proper calibration of each Alcotest being used by police departments across the State of New Jersey and around the United States.
It is the opinion of the undersigned that the burden rests on the State to show by clear and convincing evidence that the Alcotest calibration was done correctly. As the underlying discovery fails to show absolutely anything, it is my opinion that the State has failed to meet its burden and the Alcotest should not be admissible absent the data and procedures utilized for each certificate.
Science should not be paramount to skepticism or the rights of defendants to defend themselves.
Talk to a lawyer about your case
If you are facing a charge or a family court matter in New Jersey or New York, request a free consultation or call 1-833-NY-NJ-LAW. See also: New Jersey DWI defense, New York DWI defense, Motions to suppress.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The law may have changed since it was written. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.